A Journey of Second Chances: My Thoughts on Fool Me Once by Catherine Bybee
When I first stumbled upon Fool Me Once, the title sparked an immediate curiosity. It seemed like a playful wink at love’s often messy nature. As a fan of Catherine Bybee’s previous work, I was eager to dive into her latest offering. Little did I know that this enchanting tale of newfound friendship and romance would capture my heart and keep me on the edge of my seat.
In Fool Me Once, we meet Lori Cumberland, a cynic in the world of matrimony, turned divorce attorney. Her motto—“Love is grand, but divorce is a hundred grand”—sums up her jaded outlook perfectly. As someone who’s witnessed the ups and downs of love through her clients, Lori has sworn off any notion of love for herself. But sometimes, life has other plans, right? A celebratory cruise with her recent clients turns into an unexpected adventure when she crosses paths with Reed Barlow, a charming private investigator whose smile and demeanor quickly break through her defenses.
The chemistry between Lori and Reed is electric, and Bybee masterfully crafts the tension that simmers just beneath the surface. As their flirtation blossoms, the reader is treated to a delightful push-and-pull dynamic filled with witty banter and palpable chemistry. Yet, lurking in the background is a layer of intrigue. Reed carries secrets of his own, intertwining love with a thread of suspense that keeps the reader guessing.
One of the standout aspects of Bybee’s writing is her ability to create well-rounded characters who feel relatable and vibrant. Lori’s fierce loyalty to her friends and her conflicted feelings about love resonate deeply. The camaraderie among the women—Lori, Trina, and Shannon—is depicted with warmth, reminding us of the importance of friendship, especially during tough transitions. This theme struck a chord with me, as it’s a timely reminder that sometimes our chosen family is just as significant as our blood relations.
Bybee’s prose flows effortlessly, making it easy to get lost in the narrative. The pacing is spot-on, keeping readers engaged without feeling rushed. Moments of humor are perfectly interspersed with dramatic tensions, allowing for a well-rounded reading experience. I particularly enjoyed the moments where unexpected humor surfaced, as it lightened the more serious themes of love and trust.
A quote that lingered with me was Lori’s reflection on her own heart: “Sometimes, you need to let yourself be vulnerable. That’s where the magic happens.” This poignantly ties into the overall message of the book—embracing vulnerability can lead to beautiful, unexpected outcomes.
Fool Me Once caters to a wide audience. Whether you’re a lover of contemporary romance, a fan of strong female characters, or someone who enjoys an engaging plot filled with mystery, there’s something here for you. Bybee masterfully combines different genres, making it a perfect beach read or a cozy evening escape.
Having read this novel, I find myself eagerly anticipating the next installment in the First Wives series. Bybee has crafted a world that feels impossibly rich and inviting, and I can’t wait to explore more of it. If you’re looking for a book that entwines romance, friendship, and intrigue, look no further. Fool Me Once is a delightful reminder that love, no matter how complicated or unexpected, is always worth the risk.
You can find Fool Me Once (First Wives Book 1) here >>






