Book Review: The Women on Platform Two by Laura Anthony
When I first picked up The Women on Platform Two, I was immediately drawn in by the evocative title and the promise of a rich exploration of women’s reproductive rights through the lens of interconnected lives. Laura Anthony deftly combines personal narratives with a weighty social commentary, crafting a dual-timeline story that feels both intimate and urgent. But, as I soon learned, this book is a mixed bag of powerful themes and somewhat contrived moments.
At its heart, the narrative revolves around three Irish women, each grappling with their own relationship to motherhood and autonomy. The modern timeline follows Saoirse, a young woman wrestling with the question of whether she even wants to have children. Her fate intertwines with that of Maura, an older woman traveling with a scrapbook of her activism—a poignant reminder of the battles fought for reproductive rights that many women still face today. One can’t help but admire how Anthony uses Maura’s past as a catalyst for Saoirse’s self-discovery, but I found the numerous coincidences a bit hard to swallow. For instance, how do two women, from vastly different eras and life situations, continually “bump into” each other in such pivotal moments? It sometimes felt like the plot was more of a series of convenient scenarios than a fluid narrative.
The 1960s timeline introduces us to a younger Maura, who leaves behind a promising career for what appears to be a fairy-tale marriage. However, as her life unfolds, this supposed dream morphs into a nightmare—a controlling and abusive marriage that isolates her from the support system she once knew. Here, Anthony touches on themes of oppression and resilience, as Maura befriends Bernie, a butcher’s wife faced with her own harrowing pregnancy. Their friendship roots the narrative in a shared experience of urgency and necessity concerning reproductive health, though it often strays into territory that felt almost like a test case rather than a genuine exploration.
What’s memorable is Maura’s transformation into an activist, going public about her plight in a society where contraception was illegal. Although her journey is filled with strength, it also felt rushed—like she became the face of a movement almost overnight. The abrupt resolution to her abusive situation, including her husband’s conveniently timed demise, felt unsatisfying. While I appreciated Maura’s journey to self-empowerment—especially when Saoirse learns to embrace the possibility of happiness without children—the series of neat conclusions sometimes undercut the weight of the issues at play.
Laura Anthony’s writing exudes passion, but at times, the pacing and structural choices felt uneven. The juxtaposition of modern-day dilemmas with historical struggles is a brilliant tactic, yet it occasionally veered into melodrama, diminishing the story’s emotional resonance. Still, the essence of courage and resilience in the face of systemic adversity shines through, offering moments of connection that are hard to ignore.
I would recommend The Women on Platform Two to anyone interested in feminist literature, especially those drawn to discussions around reproductive rights. While it may falter in places, its heart is in the right place. Ultimately, this novel prompted me to reflect on the boundaries of women’s autonomy and the interconnectedness of our stories. It reminded me that every woman’s journey is not just personal but part of a larger tapestry of shared experiences and struggles. If you’re looking for a book that combines social issues with personal narratives, this is certainly one to consider.
Discover more about The Women on Platform Two on GoodReads >>